Christmas Letter 2024

Cookies for Christmas

Everyone is already stuffed with sugar from our messy tradition of decorating gingerbread houses, but a batch of our family’s favorite chocolate chip cookies still seems like a good idea. As soon as the words left my dad’s mouth, time slowed as we raced to the fridge to check off the logistics: Did we have enough eggs? Butter? Did the chocolate chips just look slightly funky, or were they too old to use? Tyler plopped one in his mouth and once he appeared free of any chocolate-borne deadly diseases, my dad had the butter in the microwave and the mixing bowls on the counter.

Like I’m sure many moms do, mine has a self-acclaimed famous chocolate chip cookie recipe. If you’re nodding your head right now and thinking about your own gorgeous cookies, here is why our recipe has got yours beat: it contains two entire sticks of butter that shine as yellow as the sun from the inside of the mixing bowl, (almost) two cups of sugar that cover the butter in a light, powdery sprinkle similar to that of a first snowfall, and as many melty chocolate chips as can be crammed into the batter. Plus, they can and do get made whenever the urge strikes. Two of the Thingelstads know the recipe by heart, and the other two know exactly how to ask the first two to repeat the ingredient list, time after time. They oblige because they know that their words will be whipped up, portioned out on a pan, and delivered right back into their mouth once chewy and golden brown. Every month or so, the cookies are made by a rotating member of the family that is ironically rarely my mom. Tyler might jump the gun when he has a late-night craving, my dad when his baker gene gets turned on and he just “feels like a little something”, and me when I am home and wanting to remind myself what chocolate chip cookies taste like when they aren’t made in a cafeteria.

The cookies were made as much as ever this year, but a few notable instances stand out. The first being a time when that extra sweetness from a good cookie really was necessary, after we lost Don / Dad / Grandpa Don in January. It was anything but sudden, so thankfully everyone got the chance to say their goodbyes on their own time, with endless back scratches or just sitting and talking, or not talking at all. I will always remember my grandpa when I crack open a tub of creamed honey and know that his would have been better, watch a round of softball and guess at the critique he would have made, or pass on one of his many stories, any one of which would be stunning enough to draw a crowd.

The next time I remember biting into one of my mom’s cookies, it was summer and the long, warm days were chock full of runs, walks and bike rides around the lakes. Ice cream was starting to gain more appeal than cookies. No sooner had the sun come out, however, than we were packing up pants and rain jackets for an epic excursion to Ireland! Among the crazier things we got to experience were multiple castles (both ruins in the countryside and fancy, functioning mansions with every amenity imaginable. We even stayed in one!), the fanciest afternoon tea, the Titanic Museum, so many rounds of fish and chips that only got better and better, one of the top five beaches in the world, and hikes and bike rides through the lush countryside that ultimately gave way to terrifyingly impressive coastal cliffs. We got our Gaelic on, even if that meant we practically screamed “tourist” sometimes.

Not too long afterward, my mom and I road-tripped to Detroit in honor of our dad/grandpa, stopping at some legendary sights along the 10 hour drive. We visited Saugatuck, Michigan (a long-time favorite city), saw Imagine Dragons (a long-time favorite band) perform their new album, and visited the Ford Museum and Bon Bon Bon chocolates (a somewhat-new-time world changing chocolate discovery).

Tyler started high school one day before I moved back to college, and the occasion called for one final batch of summer sendoff cookies. Per our usual routine, Tyler measured and I mixed, and we set the cookies to bake amidst him debriefing the first day of school and me shoving clothes into bags. I packed a few to welcome myself into my new dorm room which, I think is worth noting, is room 911 in one of the two tower dorms on campus. Not only was I moving into a new room, but a new role as a New Student Orientation leader, where for a week my partner and I got to “drop off” and “pick up” our group of college freshmen from various orientation events and lead them in get-to-know each other games of duck-duck-grey duck (goose?) and two truths and a lie. It was epic- all the goofy and crazy you get at summer camp without any of the complaints.

As fall wore on, all of the life going on squashed cookie making time. Three separate visits to the state fair appeased my mom’s new found love of Peachie’s donuts and my dad’s penchant for visiting various hot tub and sauna companies. After collecting phone numbers and internalizing the sales pitch given to him by a hundred different sales guys with the same winning smile, my dad convinced himself that a spa area was just what our cabin needed. Fast forward to today, and you’ll understand why you see him and my brother (and me, a lot of the time) walking outside in winter temps wearing a swimsuit. My mom has yet to attempt the hot tub or sauna- call it scaredy-cat behavior or call it sensible- but she has committed to walking around the lake almost every day, which is her way of simultaneously facing the cold and keeping the doctor away (she’s got the apple part down, too). Having spent the past few months learning from nutrition and longevity experts, she has become the new health guru around town. Tyler was quick to join his school’s debate team and relishes walking the halls of a high school that kicks every other high school’s butt (and budget!). AP Human Geography (iconic) and debate tournaments (also iconic, just not for me) compose most of what I hear about school from him. He spent a good chunk of time and money throughout the year building a PC and equipping it with a fancy light up keyboard and fans, along with a gaming desk. All worries about college can be dispelled, as this year I suddenly seem to know half of the St.Olaf population and have made some truly amazing friends. Every moment not spent talking to people, in class, or doing homework (in that order) is occupied with one of two jobs, singing in Chapel choir or my a capella group “The Folks”, having a Noah Kahan “jam sesh” on the guitar, or running and biking around Northfield. Our dog Lucky, when not barking uncontrollably at other dogs, observed this action-packed year from her favorite two perches: my parent’s bed and her signature spot on the stairs.

And that brings us back to the cookie-making spree that I am currently watching unfold. T oday was one of those times when all the sugar you have already eaten starts talking and convinces you that consuming even more sugar is the solution to your sugar problem. In my opinion it’s moments like these- the unexpected, the spontaneous, the pockets of joy and silliness hidden in the everyday- that give the holiday season its true sweetness.

Sending you and yours a sugary-sweet holiday! XOXO Mazie